shifta and deband weapon

[Hrith]

Kefka, are you counting S-Rank daggers?

S-Rank Blade
let's see...

Red Dagger
Requirement 600 ATP
ATP +245-280
Grind +65
Ground ATP +375-410
ATA +35
Special = Unreduced Soul

Lavis Blade
Requirement 850 ATP
ATP +430-450
ATA +40
Special = Lavis

S-Red's Blade
Requirement 821 ATP
ATP +340-350
Grind +15
Ground ATP +370-380
ATA +39
Special = Shifta or Deband Lv 3

S-Rank Blade
Requirement 800 ATP
ATP +10
Grind +200
Ground ATP +410
ATA +35

So Lavis Blade is #1, no contest.

Then let's take average ATP of the 3 other daggers:
S-Rank Blade = 410 ATP
S-Red's Blade = 375 ATP
Red Dagger = 392 ATP

S-Red's Blade seems weaker, but...
Of the four hunters, three do not have Shifta, with Shifta, S-Red's Blade is more powerful (not by much).
And most importantly, Red Dagger and S-Rank Blade have 35 ATA, S-Red's has 39 ATA, and as you all know, ATA is vital, especially on hunters.

In the end, #2 dagger would be either S-Rank Blade or S-Red's Blade, depending on your char, and if you can afford to put a good special on the S-Rank Blade.

But Red Dagger is definitely #4; the unreduced Soul special is very nice for non-droids, and it's the easiest to find of the 3 (S-Rank cannot be found, duh), but the other daggers have more pros.

I say S-Red's is #2, because S-Rank cannot have hit%, and 35 ATA is very low on HUmar, HUnewearl and HUcast, they cannot make good use of the special (if you add one).

#1 Lavis Blade (pwnz0rz)
#2 S-Red's Blade (good ATP, ATA and special)
#3 S-Rank Blade (uber special available)
#4 Red Dagger (Unreduced Soul, easiest one with nice %)