Brightness circle vs aura field

[A.S.]

here are the stats of all armours for GC/BB/Xbox: http://romain.bernardi.free.fr/pso/guardstats.html

I'm missing Ep4 armours (but they are in the database).

I say Brightness Circle does not stand a chance, Aura field is the best armour in the game, simple as that.

EDK is pretty useless for Caves, unless your piping in Caves, more crucial in Temple (Caves is very wide, enough space to eithe run or hide form Megid). I would use Aura Field (easier to find then Brightness Circle=better stats) and equip ResistDevil.

EDIT: Miscalculated my Sacred Cloth's defense, sorry >_<