21-03-2005, 08:50 PM
They are ties. You can't slur the same note on a piano. 
I haven't downloaded Noteworthy yet, so I can only see the attachment .png, but could you please change:
Bar 5: remove the last note and make the G into a dotted minim (3-beats).
Bar 22: please add the G natural. This note's makes a slight dischord, but it's quite important. (There's also a redundant # symbol on the C, lol. My mistake. It'll be a C# already anyway).
Bar 18: thanks for pointing this out: the last two notes of the bass clef should be quavers, not crotchets. The last beat is a crotchet rest.
The middle of bar 8 is the end of a phrase. The last two notes of bar 8 are in free time, much like the two notes at the very beginning of the piece. I can quite imagine the sudden "awkward silence" the computer will produce. Even if you tell the computer to hold the notes, it'll still sound far too mechanical. Maybe it's the Android's version
of the piece.
Performed by a human (Newman too??), the piece should sound just like the original. That is what I'm trying to achieve with this score, really. It's a little slower than the Noteworthy version, and quite easy (Grade 2-3 on UK's ABRSM exam board?) to perform. Try it yourself and hear the difference 
.
I haven't downloaded Noteworthy yet, so I can only see the attachment .png, but could you please change:
Bar 5: remove the last note and make the G into a dotted minim (3-beats).
Bar 22: please add the G natural. This note's makes a slight dischord, but it's quite important. (There's also a redundant # symbol on the C, lol. My mistake. It'll be a C# already anyway).
Bar 18: thanks for pointing this out: the last two notes of the bass clef should be quavers, not crotchets. The last beat is a crotchet rest.
Quote:It might not sound right but when you play things in real life you can always slightly change things and aren't accurate so sound bett/worse. With computers it's exact .I just downloaded the Noteworthy-played mp3s, but I don't like them. It's not a good idea to use a computer for pieces in "tempo rubato", which means not needing to keep to a strict strict rhythm (in order to express feeling). Please listen to the original again (link in last post). You'll notice immediately.
The middle of bar 8 is the end of a phrase. The last two notes of bar 8 are in free time, much like the two notes at the very beginning of the piece. I can quite imagine the sudden "awkward silence" the computer will produce. Even if you tell the computer to hold the notes, it'll still sound far too mechanical. Maybe it's the Android's version
of the piece.Performed by a human (Newman too??
), the piece should sound just like the original. That is what I'm trying to achieve with this score, really. It's a little slower than the Noteworthy version, and quite easy (Grade 2-3 on UK's ABRSM exam board?) to perform. Try it yourself and hear the difference .
| Mirinee | FOmarl | PURPLENUM | Green Robes | Level 190 | PSOBB Skyline 1 | ![[Image: ArkzB.gif]](http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b293/Mirinee/ArkzB.gif)